Gotham Steel Stackmaster Cookware Set Reviews

Adriana Lindsey December 17, 2023 6 0

SaveSavedRemoved 0

We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.

Have those late-night infomercials convinced you that the Gotham Steel Stackmaster cookware set will revolutionize your kitchen? You’ve seen the ads – eggs sliding across non-stick pans, cheese melting without sticking. It seems too good to be true. As tempting as it sounds, you have to wonder if these pans actually work as advertised or if they’re just another gimmick that ends up being a pain to clean.

Before you drop a chunk of change on this cookware set, you need the real scoop from people who have actually cooked with these pans. We tested every piece in the Gotham Steel Stackmaster set to determine if these non-stick wonders are kitchen magic or just another nightmare waiting to happen. Here’s everything you need to know before you buy.

Table of Contents

Top 5 Best Gotham Steel Cookware Set

Image	Product	Amazon
	Gotham Steel 14” Nonstick Frying Pan with Ultra Durable Mineral and Diamond	Check Price
	Gotham Steel 10 Pc Hammered Copper Pots and Pans Set Nonstick Cookware Set,	Check Price
	Gotham Steel Copper Cast 10 Piece Pots and Pans Set with Ultra Nonstick Diamond Surface	Check Price
	Gotham Steel 20 Pc Copper Pots and Pans Set Nonstick Cookware Set, Pot and Pan Set,	Check Price
	Gotham Steel Hammered Collection Pots and Pans 10 Piece Premium Ceramic Cookware Set	Check Price

Gotham Steel Stackmaster Cookware Set: Overview and Features

The Gotham Steel Stackmaster set comes with 10 pieces of nonstick cookware so you can cook entire meals without needing any other pots or pans. The star of the show is the 9.5-inch frying pan, great for sautéing veggies, searing meat, or scrambling eggs. With its ceramic nonstick coating, you only need a tiny bit of oil and cleanup is a breeze.

The 3 saucepans (1.5qt, 2.5qt, 4.2qt) have tempered glass lids so you can see how your pasta sauce or risotto is simmering away. The included steamer basket fits in the largest saucepan, perfect for dim sum or steamed dumplings. For stockpots, you get a 6qt and 8qt, handy when you’re cooking for a crowd or meal prepping.

All the cookware is made of sturdy aluminum with stainless steel handles that stay cool to the touch. They’re all oven-safe up to 500°F, so you can brown them on the stovetop and then finish them in the oven. The set is also dishwasher safe but for best results, hand wash with a soft sponge to maintain the nonstick coating.

With the Stackmaster set, you’ll have high-quality, durable pots and pans to handle any cooking task. From searing a steak to boiling pasta to sautéing garlic, this affordable cookware set delivers nonstick convenience and performance. Your new stackable, space-saving best friends are here! Now, what’s for dinner?

Testing the Gotham Steel Stackmaster Pans

To really put these pans to the test, we cooked up a storm in the Stackmaster set. Here’s how each pan performed:

Fry Pan

This 10-inch fry pan is ideal for sautéing veggies, scrambling eggs, and searing meat. Its nonstick coating lived up to the hype, releasing foods effortlessly without oil. We found the pan heated evenly and was incredibly easy to clean. A stellar all-purpose pan for any stovetop.

Saucepan

The 2-quart saucepan worked great for making pasta sauce, steaming rice, and reheating soups. Again, its nonstick surface prevented burning and made washing up a breeze. Our only complaint was its small size, suitable for individuals or couples but not bigger families. For its intended use, though, this pan hit the mark.

Stockpot

The largest pan, an 8-quart stockpot, bubbled away for hours making beef bone broth, vegetable soup, and chili. Its generous size handled these tasks with ease and would also work for canning or seafood boils. After prolonged use, some staining occurred, but a good scrub removed most marks. For long-simmering recipes, this pot excelled.

Overall, the Gotham Steel Stackmaster set proved its nonstick mettle and metal-utensil-safe claims in our tests. While pan sizes suit smaller households, performance was superb. For fuss-free, healthy cooking without oil, these pans deliver. At their budget-friendly price, the Stackmaster collection earns our recommendation for an all-around useful, hardworking set of pots and pans.

Cleaning and Care of the Gotham Steel Stackmaster Set

Cleaning and caring for your Gotham Steel Stackmaster set properly will help ensure years of use. These pots and pans have a non-stick coating that makes cooking and cleanup a breeze, but it does require some extra TLC.

Hand Washing

It’s best to hand wash the Gotham Steel Stackmaster pieces to maximize their lifespan. While the non-stick coating is scratch-resistant, the harsh chemicals and high heat of the dishwasher can damage the coating over time. Fill your sink with warm, soapy water and wash each pan thoroughly with a soft sponge or nylon scrubber. Avoid using abrasive cleaners, strong detergents, and metal utensils which can scratch the surface. Rinse well and dry completely to prevent water spots.

No Metal Utensils

Only use wood, nylon or heat-resistant silicone utensils with your Gotham Steel Stackmaster set. Metal utensils, even when used carefully, can scratch and damage the non-stick coating. Scratches in the coating mean food is more likely to stick, and small bits of the coating can end up in your food.

Conditioning the Pans

To help your Gotham Steel Stackmaster pans maintain their non-stick magic, season or condition them regularly. Wipe the pan with oil and heat until the oil polymerizes, about 5 minutes. Let cool and wipe out excess with a paper towel. Do this after every few uses or if you notice food starting to stick. The oil will fill in any microscopic pores and help prevent sticking.

Storage

Never stack items on top of your Gotham Steel Stackmaster pans, as this can cause scratches and dents in the non-stick coating. Store them separately or with padding like dish towels between them. Keeping your pans in a dry, cool spot away from extreme heat will help maximize their lifespan.

With proper care and cleaning, your Gotham Steel Stackmaster set should provide many non-stick meals to come. Following these tips will ensure your pans stay as slick and scratch-free as the day you bought them.

Gotham Steel Stackmaster vs. Other Cookware Sets

The Gotham Steel Stackmaster set is a popular, budget-friendly cookware option, but how does it compare to other well-known brands? Here are some of the main differences to consider before you buy.

Price

At under $200 for a 12-piece set, the Gotham Steel Stackmaster is very affordable. Sets from brands like All-Clad, Calphalon, and Cuisinart typically start around $300 to $500 for similar pieces. The nonstick coating and aluminum construction help keep costs down while still providing good performance for the price.

Materials

The Gotham Steel set uses aluminum and a ceramic nonstick coating called Ti-Cerama. Other brands often use higher-end materials like anodized aluminum, stainless steel, or multi-ply constructions with copper or aluminum cores. These can heat more evenly and last longer, but at a higher price. The Ti-Cerama coating is PTFE-free but may not last as long as some PTFE coatings from other brands.

Nonstick Performance

The Stackmaster set gets very high marks for nonstick performance right out of the box. Eggs, pancakes, and more slide right off with little to no oil needed. However, the nonstick coating may start to deteriorate over time with heavy or improper use. Other brands using PTFE coatings, like Teflon, can often provide better long-term nonstick ability if properly cared for.

Handle Comfort

The Stackmaster set has soft-touch silicone handles that are comfortable to grip but not oven-safe. Other brands frequently offer riveted stainless steel or cast handles that can handle higher oven temperatures. If stovetop cooking is your priority, the silicone handles work great, but for oven use, other options would probably suit you better.

In the end, the Gotham Steel Stackmaster set offers solid value and performance for basic stovetop cooking at a budget-friendly price. However, for higher-end performance, material quality or versatility, you may want to consider other well-known cookware brands, even if you have to spend a bit more. The choice comes down to your specific needs, priorities, and, of course, your budget.

Our Verdict: Is the Gotham Steel Stackmaster Worth Buying?

After testing each piece in the Gotham Steel Stackmaster cookware set, we can recommend this product with a few caveats. The non-stick coating lives up to the hype and makes cooking and cleaning a breeze. However, to get the most out of these pans, you need to follow the care instructions properly.

For the price, this set offers fantastic value. The variety of pans covers nearly all your stovetop cooking needs. From scrambled eggs to stir fry, the non-stick surfaces distribute heat evenly and allow you to use less oil. Cleanup only requires hot, soapy water—no scrubbing required! The stackable, space-saving design is ideal for small kitchens.

However, to keep the non-stick coating intact, only use wooden or heat-resistant plastic utensils. Metal utensils will scratch the coating, as will harsh abrasive cleaners. Hand wash the pans after each use and avoid putting them in the dishwasher. With proper care, the non-stick coating should last at least a couple of years. If it starts to deteriorate or chip badly, it’s best to replace the pans.

For the budget-conscious home cooks looking to upgrade their cookware, the Gotham Steel Stackmaster set is a great choice. If taken care of according to the instructions, these pans will serve you well for everyday cooking tasks. While the non-stick coating may not last forever, at this price point, you’ll still get your money’s worth from this versatile, space-saving set.

Conclusion

So there you have it, a full review of the Gotham Steel Stackmaster Cookware Set put through its paces. For the price, you really can’t beat the non-stick performance and versatility of this set. The pans heat evenly, and clean up like a dream, and the stackable space-saving design is perfect for smaller kitchens. While some pieces like the saucepan handles could use improvement, overall this affordable set delivers solid results for everyday cooking tasks. If you’re on the hunt for a durable, dishwasher-safe non-stick cookware set that won’t break the bank, the Gotham Steel Stackmaster collection deserves a spot on your stovetop. Happy cooking!