Allen and Roth Cabinets vs KraftMaid: Which is Right for You?


We may earn money or products from the companies mentioned in this post.

Looking for a new kitchen? Allen and Roth and KraftMaid are two popular cabinet brands, but which one is right for you? This comparison guide will help you weigh the pros and cons of each brand so you can make the best decision for your home.

You know you need new cabinets in your kitchen. You’ve lived with those particle board boxes from the 1980s long enough. It’s time for an upgrade to something solid that will last and make all your Instagram followers jealous. But now you’re stuck choosing between Allen and Roth cabinets and KraftMaid. How’s an amateur renovator supposed to decide between two brands that seem pretty comparable? Never fear, we’ve done the research for you so you can avoid buyer’s remorse. Whether you’re on a budget or want high-end custom cabinets, we’ve got the lowdown on style options, construction, pricing, and reviews from real homeowners like yourself to help you determine which brand is right for your kitchen and your wallet. So pour yourself another cup of coffee and keep reading. By the end of this, you’ll be confidently marching into your local home improvement store, ready to make a choice you won’t regret.

Overview of Allen and Roth vs KraftMaid Cabinets

So you’re in the market for new kitchen cabinets and have narrowed it down to Allen and Roth vs KraftMaid. It’s a tough choice—they’re both solid mid-range options that won’t break the bank. Let’s break down the pros and cons so you can make an informed decision.

KraftMaid is the larger company, churning out cabinets since 1945. They offer more styles and finishes to choose from, so if customization is your thing, KraftMaid’s your brand. They’re also a bit more budget-friendly. The downside? Some designs feel cookie-cutter, and the quality can be inconsistent.

Allen and Roth is Lowe’s in-house cabinet brand. They focus on versatile, simple styles that suit most kitchens. You’ll get good quality for the price, and installation is a cinch since they’re designed to work with Lowe’s countertops and appliances. However, the selection is more limited, and some units seem cheaply made.

In the end, it comes down to what matters most to you. If you want lots of style options at a low cost, go to KraftMaid. If quality components and easy installation are bigger priorities, Allen & Roth is your winner. Either way, you can’t go wrong. These wallet-friendly brands will give you a kitchen you’ll love without the luxury price tag.

So take a deep breath and choose—you’ve got this! Once you do, start dreaming about how good that first home-cooked meal is going to taste in your new space. Decisions don’t get much more delicious than that!

Key Differences Between Allen and Roth and KraftMaid

When it comes to cabinetry, you have options. Lots of options. Two of the big names in the cabinet game are Allen and Roth and KraftMaid. They’re comparable in price and style, so how do you choose? Here are a few key differences to consider before you commit to a kitchen full of their handiwork.


Allen and Roth use a mix of woods and laminates in their cabinets, so you can go high-end or low-end. KraftMaid sticks to the hard stuff: wood, wood, and more wood. We’re talking oak, hickory, maple, and cherry. No laminate is in sight. So if you’re a wood purist, KraftMaid has you covered.


Want cabinets in colors not found in nature? Allen and Roth offer a variety of painted finishes to match your funky style. They also have more sizes and configurations for awkward kitchen spaces. KraftMaid leans more traditional, with classic wood stains and standard cabinet dimensions.


KraftMaid is known for high-quality craftsmanship and boxes that last. Allen and Roth get mixed reviews, with some complaints about durability. But for the price, their cabinets should still last 10–15 years with normal use.


You’ll usually pay a premium for KraftMaid’s high-quality wood and construction. Allen & Roth is typically more budget-friendly. In the end, you get what you pay for.

So weigh what matters most in your kitchen and choose wisely. Whatever you decide, may your cabinets contain as much (or as little) as possible and your drawers glide smoothly for years to come.

Pros and Cons of Allen and Roth Cabinets

When it comes to Allen and Roth vs. KraftMaid cabinets, there are some pros and cons to weigh. On the one hand, Allen and Roth offer budget-friendly stock cabinets that won’t break the bank. But on the other hand, KraftMaid has higher-quality custom options if you’ve got the dough. Decisions, decisions.

Allen and Roth Cabinets

Pros of Allen and Roth

  • Allen and Roth is Lowes’ in-house cabinet brand, so their stock cabinets are very affordable. If you’re on a tight budget or just want to keep costs down, Allen and Roth can’t be beat.
  • They offer simple Shaker-style cabinets that are neutral and timeless.
  • Assembly is straightforward for the DIYer. The parts are pre-cut, and all you need is a drill/driver and some patience.

Cons of Allen and Roth

  • You get what you pay for. These are basic, no-frills cabinets made of laminate or medium-density fiberboard (MDF). Don’t expect solid wood or dovetail joinery.
  • Limited style and size options. You’re stuck with whatever’s in stock.
  • susceptible to damage over time. The materials aren’t the most durable and may dent, scratch, or warp more easily.

Allen and Roth Cabinets Check Price on Amazon

KraftMaid Cabinets

Pros of KraftMaid

  • High-quality, all-wood cabinets with dovetail joinery and solid construction. These babies are built to last.
  • Huge selection of styles, finishes, and customization options. Get exactly what you want.
  • Environmentally-friendly. Many of their wood products are certified by the Sustainable Forestry Initiative.

Cons of KraftMaid

  • Much more expensive, often 2-3 times the cost of Allen and Roth. Premium cabinets at a premium price.
  • Longer lead times. It can take 6–8 weeks for custom cabinets to arrive.
  • Complicated installation. These cabinets may require an experienced cabinet installer to put them in properly. Not ideal for DIY.

KraftMaid Cabinets Check Price on Amazon

In the end, you need to weigh the pros and cons of each brand based on your needs, budget, timeline, and skills. If cost is a concern, Allen and Roth will work in a pinch. But if quality is more important and you want cabinets that will stand the test of time, KraftMaid is probably your best bet. The choice is yours!

Pros and Cons of KraftMaid Cabinets

So you’re eyeing those KraftMaid cabinets, aren’t you? Before you sign over your life savings to the big “K,” consider what you’re really getting into. Sure, KraftMaid is a reputable brand that’s been around for decades. But are their cabinets truly superior, or are you just paying for the name?

The “Pros”—If You Like Paying More

KraftMaid touts features like dovetail joinery, soft-close hardware, and multiple wood and finish options. All fancy terms to justify their inflated price tags. Their variety of styles means you can achieve a custom built-in look if that’s what you’re after. And their cabinets do come with a lifetime warranty in case anything goes awry.

The “Cons”—Your Wallet Will Hate You

Expect to pay 20–50% more for KraftMaid versus comparable brands like Allen + Roth. While Kraftmaid’s wood and construction quality are decent, you’re really paying a premium just for the brand’s cachet. Their endless style and finish options also mean more opportunities for upcharges. While that lifetime warranty provides peace of mind, most homeowners will move on to a new house before experiencing any issues with properly installed cabinets.

The Bottom Line

If money is no object and you want the perceived prestige of a well-known brand, KraftMaid will make you proud. But if you’re on a budget, Allen + Roth and other affordable brands will provide comparable quality at a lower cost. Focus on the materials, joinery, and features that really matter to you rather than paying more just for a brand name. Your bank account will thank you, and you can feel good about putting that extra cash towards a nice kitchen island or countertops instead.

So before you get swept away by KraftMaid’s marketing hype, weigh your options objectively. Allen + Roth cabinets may be the choice that’s “just right” for your needs and budget. You’ll end up with a kitchen you love for less. And isn’t that really what Goldilocks would want?

Which Brand Is Right for Your Kitchen Remodel?

So you’ve decided to remodel your kitchen, and now comes the tricky part—choosing the cabinets. Allen and Roth or KraftMaid? It’s a debate that could rage as fiercely as pine vs. oak or quartz vs. granite. But don’t stress—we’re here to help you figure out which brand is the right match for your culinary castle.

Style and Selection

When it comes to style options, KraftMaid has Allen and Roth beat. They offer cabinets in just about every color under the sun, from ebony to washed oak. Plus, they have more door profiles to choose from, like arched cathedrals and recessed panels. If you want a kitchen that looks straight out of a design magazine, KraftMaid is probably your best bet.

That said, Allen and Roth still have a respectable range of styles at a lower price point. For budget-friendly shakers or traditional cabinets, they’ll do nicely. They may have fewer bells and whistles, but they’ll get the job done, and your wallet will thank you.

Quality and Construction

If you’re looking for cabinets with furniture-grade quality, KraftMaid is the clear winner. They use higher-quality materials and more durable construction, so their cabinets will typically last longer. The trade-off, of course, is that you’ll pay significantly more.

Allen and Roth offer decent quality at a lower cost. Their cabinets should hold up fine for regular use but may show signs of wear and tear sooner. For a kitchen on a budget, though, Allen and Roth is a perfectly suitable choice.

In the end, you have to weigh your priorities and choose what’s right for your needs and price range. A kitchen remodel is a big investment, so make sure you go with a brand you can live with for years to come, through thick and thin—or at least until the next remodel!


So there you have it, the pros and cons of Allen and Roth vs KraftMaid cabinetry laid bare for your consideration. At the end of the day, only you can decide which brand’s mix of style, quality, and budget-friendliness is right for your kitchen aspirations. Just remember, whatever you choose, your friends will judge you for it. They may claim cabinet envy or scoff at your bourgeois tastes, but pay them no mind. This is your kitchen, your palace, and your place of culinary adventures and late-night snack attacks. Choose wisely but without regret, secure in the knowledge that you’ll be living with these cabinets for years to come, each time you reach for a glass or grab a pan. The cabinets of your dreams await. Now go forth and customize! The home improvement gods smile upon you.

More Best Kitchen & Dining recommendations

We will be happy to hear your thoughts

      Leave a reply

      EX Kitchen